I reported two years ago (here and here) about the firing of Ali and Shahla Afshari from their jobs at the National Institute For Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) in Morgantown, WV, because they they “failed to pass a background check” that they didn't even know was happening. Nor have they ever been told of the reasons that they failed. The Afshari's are Iranian natives who had been in the country 18 years when they were fired. They had passed background checks when they were hired in 1996 and in 1997.
And what was the high security work they did at NIOSH? Ali built equipment to study the health effects of welding and asphalt fumes and hand and arm vibrations and Shala worked in a laboratory that researched sensitivity to chemicals in the work place, such as allergic reactions to latex gloves.
Two years later, the Charleston Gazette follows up on the story. The Afshari's still have not learned why they were fired, but they have learned a few new things thanks to a lawsuit they filed. For example,
- A government official has recanted her sworn testimony about the couple. The official once said she received a briefing from security officials and then recommended their termination. Now, she says that her earlier sworn testimony was “not consistent” with her current “recollection of matters.”
- Long before they were fired, the Federal Bureau of Investigation had conducted a routine check on the couple, decided they were not a security threat and closed their file.
- The government officials in Atlanta who recommended their firing never interviewed their neighbors, co-workers or supervisors in Morgantown.
The FBI had closed its file on Ali Afshari before officials at the CDC and NIOSH decided to fire the couple, according to a deposition by FBI agent Gary Stoops and a redacted copy of Ali Afshari’s FBI file obtained by their lawyers.The Afsharis are asking to be re-instated in their jobs and reimbursed for attorneys fees and two years of lost income. Of course, the damage has been done:
Many of the government officials involved in the Afsharis’ case never saw the supposed evidence against them. One man who did and who recommended their termination was William Porter, director of the Office of Security and Emergency Preparedness at the CDC in Atlanta.
His wife is Diane Porter, who was deputy director for management at NIOSH. At first, Diane Porter said she was very involved in the decision to fire the Afsharis. In a sworn statement, she said she recommended to NIOSH Director John Howard that they be terminated.
Howard himself did not have the security clearance to see the information being used to justify their firing, so he testified that he relied on Diane Porter’s advice.
But in a later sworn statement to the court, Diane Porter took back much of her previous testimony. She said that she couldn’t remember whether she had that conversation with Howard.
But no settlement could make up for what they have suffered, Ali Afshari says. That day shook the family to its very core, he said. It shook their faith in themselves and in the United States but did not destroy it, he said. For even as the U.S. government fought them in court, they decided to start the process to become permanent citizens.Uh, John, Julie. This might be a good time to say "Oops, sorry. Nevermind. Our mistake. Is there anything we can do to make this up to you and your family?" Sure hope you don't disappoint them. These days we need more Americans like the Afsharis.
“The foundation of this country is strong,” he said. “What a few individuals did, that does not undermine what this country is.
“Freedom is not an easy thing,” he added. “Sometimes we must fight for it.”
Azadeh Afshari said this experience has been a test of the best ideals of America. If her family can receive justice, then she will believe ideals such as due process and freedom of religion are more than just words on a piece of paper.
Ali Afshari remains hopeful about the future of his adopted country. He said his family’s ordeal has led him to appreciate the true strength of America.
“The beauty of this country is not its land. The beauty of this country is not its wealth,” he said. “The beauty of America is our Constitution and the laws we have.”