Finkel argues that in order to determine what level of beryllium caused the sensitization, it must be known how much beryllium the inspectors were exposed to. OSHA is refusing to release exposure data, arguing that "the data available is limited to sampling and inspection history, not exposure in the traditional industrial hygiene sense."
"Ridiculous," is what several other prominent industrial hygienists and physicians called OSHA's argument that its sampling data is not "exposure in the traditional industrial hygiene sense," according to Finkel's letter.
The information OSHA declines to release offers a "fantastic scientific opportunity to define the lower levels of exposures and their relationship to beryllium sensitization," according to Peter Lurie, MD, MPH, deputy director of Public Citizen's health research group. Lurie believes, "The data are at a level of detail that exceeds what we usually have in occupational health studies."
Brush Wellman, a major supplier of beryllium, agrees with OSHA, apparently fearing that the information will reveal that beryllium sensitization can be caused by lower levels of exposure than is currently believed.
OSHA also continues to refuse to offer testing to OSHA retirees, which Finkel calls "callous in the extreme."
Finkel was removed from his position as OSHA Regional Administrator in Denver after complaining publicly that OSHA had reversed its promise to test inspectors for beryllium sensitization. He filed a whistleblower complaint and later reached a settlement with OSHA. Finkel currently teaches at Princeton. Although he remains on OSHA's payroll, he does not speak for the agency.
Occupational Hazards has provided the complete text of Finkel's letter is available here. The text for Snare's March 24 is available here.
- Ten OSHA Staff Test Positive For Beryllium Sensitization, March 24, 2005
- Washington Post on OSHA Inspectors' Beryllium Exposure, February 1, 2005
- OSHA Inspectors: Left Twisting In The Wind, January 19, 2005
- OSHA To Test Staff For Beryllium Disease, April 28, 2004
- OSHA Regional Administrator Accuses OSHA of Refusing To Test OSHA Inspectors for Beryllium Disease, October 12, 2003